Struggling to decide between two video-making guides? VMFB offers a comprehensive technical roadmap with gear recommendations, while HSVDS focuses on timeless storytelling principles. Your ideal choice depends on whether you need practical production guidance or fundamental directorial skills to elevate your videos.
Key Takeaways:
- VMFB offers a comprehensive 5-part roadmap covering everything from equipment selection to marketing your finished videos
- HSVDS focuses on timeless storytelling principles that will improve your videos regardless of what equipment you use
- TechEd Publishers provides specific gear recommendations for different budget levels in their 2023 guide
- Both books include practical exercises, but they approach video creation from fundamentally different angles
- The ideal choice depends on whether you need technical guidance or storytelling fundamentals to improve your videos
The Video Creator’s Dilemma: Two Popular Guides, One Choice
Every aspiring video creator faces a pivotal moment – that overwhelming feeling when you realize how much you don’t know about making videos that people actually want to watch. With countless online tutorials offering fragmented advice, many beginners turn to comprehensive guidebooks to build a solid foundation.
Two books consistently rise to the top of recommendation lists: TechEd Publishers’ Video Making for Beginners (2023) and Steve Stockman’s How to Shoot Video That Doesn’t Suck (2011). If you’re serious about improving your video skills quickly, TechEd Publishers’ structured approach to video creation provides a clear roadmap that many beginners find invaluable. Despite addressing the same fundamental need – helping newcomers create better videos – these guides take remarkably different approaches to the challenge.
If you’re trying to decide which book deserves your time and money, you need to understand how their teaching philosophies differ and which aligns best with your specific video creation goals. Let’s compare these popular guides head-to-head to determine which deserves a place on your bookshelf.
Book Overview: What Each Guide Promises Beginners
Video Making for Beginners presents itself as a comprehensive roadmap for the modern content creator. Published in 2023 by TechEd Publishers, this 212-page guide promises to transform complete novices into confident video producers through a systematic approach to the entire production process.
The book is structured around a clear 5-part framework: Equipment selection, Pre-production planning, Stage setup, Shooting techniques, and Post-production workflows. Each section builds logically on the previous one, creating a cohesive learning path that mirrors an actual video production timeline. With a strong focus on practical application, VMFB includes specific equipment recommendations for different budget levels, including smartphone setups for those just starting out.
In contrast, How to Shoot Video That Doesn’t Suck takes a more philosophical approach to video creation. Steve Stockman’s 248-page guide (first published in 2011, with a revised edition available) focuses less on specific gear and more on developing what he calls the “director’s mindset.”
Rather than organizing content chronologically, HSVDS features 74 micro-chapters covering fundamental concepts of visual storytelling, shot composition, and audience engagement. Stockman, a professional director, emphasizes principles that have remained relevant since the dawn of filmmaking – techniques that work regardless of whether you’re using a smartphone or professional cinema camera.
Teaching Approaches That Shape Your Learning Journey
The educational philosophies behind these books couldn’t be more different, and understanding these distinctions is crucial for choosing the right guide for your needs.
VMFB takes a structured, classroom-ready approach. Each section concludes with specific action steps that transform theoretical knowledge into practical skills. This methodical progression feels familiar to anyone who’s taken formal courses – you learn foundational concepts first, then build upon them systematically. The book’s organization mimics an actual production workflow, making it particularly useful for project-based learning.
HSVDS, meanwhile, adopts a conversational, mentor-like tone. Stockman writes as if he’s sitting beside you during a shoot, pointing out common mistakes and offering quick fixes. Each micro-chapter focuses on a single concept, making the book easy to digest in short bursts. Rather than progressing linearly, you can jump between sections based on your immediate needs or interests.
Content Depth Comparison: What You’ll Actually Learn
1. Essential Equipment: Budget vs. Storytelling Focus
VMFB dedicates significant space to equipment selection, breaking down options into budget tiers. TechEd Publishers recognized that one of the biggest hurdles for new creators is figuring out what gear to buy without wasting money. Their book acknowledges that many beginners start with smartphones, offering specific accessory recommendations to maximize your existing device’s capabilities before investing in more expensive gear. This practical approach helps readers make informed purchasing decisions without overspending on unnecessary equipment.
In stark contrast, HSVDS deliberately minimizes equipment discussions. Stockman’s philosophy is that great videos come from understanding visual storytelling principles, not from having expensive gear. He provides only essential technical guidance, focusing instead on how to use whatever equipment you already have more effectively. This approach keeps readers from getting bogged down in specs and comparisons.
2. Shooting Techniques: Technical Skills vs. Director’s Mindset
When it comes to actual filming techniques, VMFB takes a comprehensive approach, covering everything from basic camera movements to lighting setups and sound recording. The book provides technical explanations for concepts like exposure, white balance, and framing. These are presented in straightforward language with clear diagrams and examples.
HSVDS approaches shooting techniques from a different angle entirely. Rather than focusing on technical execution, Stockman emphasizes decision-making and intentionality. His chapters cover concepts like “Think in Shots” and “Move, Point, Shoot, Stop” – simple principles that dramatically improve visual storytelling regardless of technical expertise. The book repeatedly encourages readers to think about why they’re shooting something rather than just how.
3. From Raw Footage to Finished Product: Editing Philosophies
The post-production sections of these books reveal perhaps their starkest philosophical differences. VMFB provides a step-by-step guide to the editing process, including software recommendations, organizational strategies, and technical workflows. It explains concepts like color correction, audio mixing, and transition effects in accessible language, with a focus on creating polished, professional-looking results.
Stockman’s approach to editing in HSVDS is remarkably different. Rather than focusing on software or effects, he emphasizes the power of ruthless editing decisions. His mantra of “when in doubt, cut it out” guides readers to create tighter, more engaging videos through disciplined editing choices rather than technical wizardry. The book contains minimal information about specific editing programs, instead teaching principles that apply across all software.
4. Getting Viewers: Modern Platform Strategies vs. Timeless Appeal
VMFB’s 2023 publication date gives it a significant advantage when discussing distribution. The book includes platform-specific guidance for optimizing videos on YouTube, TikTok, Instagram Reels, and other contemporary platforms. It covers thumbnail creation, keyword optimization, and posting schedules – essential knowledge for anyone hoping to build an audience in today’s crowded digital landscape.
HSVDS largely avoids platform-specific advice, which makes sense given its initial 2011 publication (predating many current platforms). Instead, Stockman focuses on creating videos with inherent appeal – content so compelling that viewers want to share it regardless of platform. His distribution advice centers on understanding your audience’s needs and creating content that genuinely addresses them.
Hands-On Learning: From Reading to Real Skills
VMFB’s Comprehensive Project Workflow
One of VMFB’s standout features is its project-based learning approach. The book guides readers through complete sample projects from concept to distribution, with detailed checklists for each production phase. These structured exercises simulate real-world video creation, allowing beginners to experience the entire workflow while creating usable portfolio pieces.
Each section concludes with specific action steps that build upon previous lessons, creating a cumulative learning experience. For example, after learning about lighting concepts, readers are tasked with setting up a three-point lighting system and shooting test footage with different configurations. This methodical approach helps transform theoretical knowledge into practical skills.
HSVDS’s Bite-Sized Practice Method
Stockman takes a markedly different approach to skill development. HSVDS features brief, focused exercises at the end of each micro-chapter, designed to isolate and reinforce specific concepts. Rather than comprehensive projects, these are quick challenges that can be completed in minutes or hours – perfect for busy learners or those who prefer incremental practice.
A typical HSVDS exercise might be “Shoot the same subject five different ways” or “Create a 30-second video with no dialogue.” These targeted drills develop specific skills without the commitment of full projects. The book encourages readers to experiment freely, emphasizing that making mistakes is an essential part of the learning process.
Real-World Skill Transfer: What Actually Sticks
The question many beginners care about most is which approach better translates to real-world skill development. The answer depends largely on your learning style and goals.
VMFB’s comprehensive workflow approach excels at preparing readers for planned video productions where all elements can be controlled. Its structured methodology helps develop systematic habits and attention to detail – valuable skills for commercial work, planned content creation, and situations where consistency matters.
HSVDS’s conceptual focus and bite-sized exercises build adaptability and creative problem-solving. These skills prove particularly valuable in dynamic shooting situations, documentary work, or any scenario where perfect conditions can’t be guaranteed. By internalizing core principles rather than rigid workflows, readers develop the flexibility to create compelling content in any circumstance.
The Truth About Each Book’s Strengths and Limitations
1. Where VMFB Delivers and Falls Short
VMFB’s greatest strength is its comprehensive coverage of the entire video production process. The book excels at providing a complete roadmap for beginners who want to understand every aspect of creating videos, from pre-production planning to distribution strategies. Its step-by-step approach leaves little to guesswork, making it particularly valuable for methodical learners who prefer clear instructions.
The book’s recency is another significant advantage. Published in 2023, VMFB includes up-to-date information on current platforms, technologies, and audience expectations. Its sections on optimizing videos for TikTok, YouTube Shorts, and Instagram Reels provide relevant guidance that older books simply cannot offer. For creators focusing on these platforms, this contemporary perspective is invaluable.
However, VMFB’s comprehensive nature is also its biggest limitation for some readers. The sheer volume of information can be overwhelming, especially for absolute beginners who might feel pressured to master every aspect of video production simultaneously. Some readers might find themselves bogged down in details before developing core competencies.
Additionally, while the book excels at explaining the ‘how’ of video production, it sometimes underemphasizes the ‘why’ – the creative decision-making that elevates videos from technically correct to genuinely engaging. Readers following VMFB’s instructions can create technically sound videos but might need additional guidance to develop their unique creative voice.
2. Where HSVDS Shines and Disappoints
HSVDS’s primary strength lies in its laser focus on storytelling principles and audience engagement. The book excels at teaching readers how to think like directors, emphasizing the fundamental concepts that make videos compelling regardless of technical specifications. This approach builds transferable skills that remain relevant even as technology evolves.
The book’s micro-chapter format and conversational tone make complex concepts accessible even to complete beginners. Stockman’s ability to distill filmmaking wisdom into memorable principles like “Move, Point, Shoot, Stop” helps readers internalize key techniques quickly. The bite-sized exercises encourage immediate application, reinforcing learning through practice rather than theory alone.
However, HSVDS deliberately avoids technical specifics, which can frustrate readers seeking concrete guidance on equipment selection or software usage. The book’s 2011 original publication date (though revised later) means it lacks information on current platforms and formats like vertical video, which have become increasingly important in today’s landscape.
Additionally, while HSVDS excels at teaching individual concepts, it provides less guidance on integrating these principles into a complete workflow. Readers may need to look elsewhere for help with project management, client communication, or other practical aspects of video production as a profession or serious hobby.
3. Direct Comparison: When to Choose Each Book
The decision between these books ultimately depends on your specific needs and learning style. Choose VMFB if:
- You prefer a structured, comprehensive approach that covers every aspect of video production
- You’re creating content specifically for current social media platforms
- You want specific guidance on equipment selection within your budget
- You learn best through complete, guided projects with clear steps
- You’re planning to create videos professionally and need business-oriented advice
On the other hand, HSVDS is likely the better choice if:
- You want to understand the timeless principles behind engaging visual storytelling
- You already have basic equipment and want to make better use of it
- You prefer learning broad concepts you can apply to any situation
- You enjoy a conversational teaching style with bite-sized exercises
- You want to develop your creative eye and directorial instincts
Finding Your Perfect Match: Which Book Is Right for You?
Creator Type A: Social Media Content Producers
If you’re primarily creating content for platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube, VMFB offers significant advantages. Its current information on platform-specific optimization, vertical video formats, and audience retention strategies directly addresses the challenges social media creators face daily.
The book’s practical advice on creating content efficiently is particularly valuable for social media creators who need to maintain consistent posting schedules. VMFB’s budget-conscious equipment recommendations also align well with the needs of creators who are building their channels without major financial backing.
While HSVDS provides valuable storytelling principles that apply to social media, its lack of platform-specific guidance means you’ll need to adapt its teachings to the unique demands of social platforms yourself.
Creator Type B: Aspiring Filmmakers and Storytellers
For those with cinematic aspirations or a strong focus on narrative content, HSVDS provides the stronger foundation. The book’s emphasis on visual storytelling, pacing, and audience engagement directly addresses the core skills filmmakers need to develop.
Stockman’s director-oriented perspective helps readers think beyond technical execution to focus on creating emotional impact through deliberate creative choices. These principles apply across formats, from short films to feature-length projects, making HSVDS a resource you can return to throughout your filmmaking journey.
While VMFB covers technical aspects of production that filmmakers need to understand, its broader focus means it offers less depth in storytelling techniques specifically.
Creator Type C: Business and Marketing Video Makers
Those creating videos for business purposes – whether marketing content, training materials, or presentation support – will likely find VMFB more immediately applicable. Its comprehensive coverage includes sections on presenting professional images, creating clear messaging, and optimizing videos for business objectives.
The book’s structured approach mirrors the planned nature of most business video production, where defined outcomes and consistent quality are essential. Its sections on efficient workflows help business creators maximize productivity while maintaining professional standards.
While HSVDS’s principles of engagement and clear communication are certainly valuable in business contexts, its creative focus may seem less directly relevant to creators working within strict brand guidelines or formal business requirements.
Find Your Perfect Video Guide
Answer 5 quick questions to discover which book matches your needs
Beyond the Books: Your Next Steps in Video Creation
Whichever guide you choose, reading alone won’t make you a better video creator. Both books emphasize the importance of practical application – actually shooting videos and learning from your successes and failures.
Consider supplementing your chosen book with resources that address its limitations. If you select VMFB, look for creative inspiration and storytelling guidance from film analysis or artistic sources. If you choose HSVDS, pair it with current technical tutorials specific to your equipment and preferred platforms.
Most importantly, establish a regular practice schedule. Even simple exercises like filming the same subject in five different ways or creating 30-second stories about everyday objects will build your skills more effectively than passive reading alone. The true value of either book emerges when you apply its principles consistently in your own work.
For beginners who want a structured approach to mastering modern video creation techniques across platforms, TechEd Publishers‘ comprehensive guide provides the roadmap you need to start creating professional-quality videos today.